Game of Thrones Blew It

I am still digesting the events of the most recent episode of Game of Thrones.  Having read a few reviews and thoughts from my friends, I figured I’d take some time to write something a little longer-form than my normally Facebook complaining.  Obviously, spoilers ahead.

In two words, I found the Battle of Winterfell to be incredibly disappointing for reasons I’ll delve into here.

Game of Thrones has done some amazing things in the last seven seasons in terms of taking long-standing fantasy and dramatic tropes and flipping them on their head.  From season 1 and Ned Stark being executed at the Sept of Baelor, we were set to know that in this world, nobody is safe, heroes die, shit happens. 

For seven seasons, all the great houses have been battling with each other for control over Westeros and the Iron Throne – I’m not always entirely sure why given that since the start of the show, kings haven’t exactly had very long lives (see: Robert Baratheon, Joffrey, Tommen) and many of the people attempting to take their seat also haven’t had the best of luck.

But, underlying all of this there has been the one existential threat: the white walkers and their army of the dead.  From the very first episode, we learned that despite all the fighting amongst the houses of the seven kingdoms, the real threat was the one that was constantly being ignored, disbelieved or uncared about by nearly everyone except Jon Snow and the night’s watch. 

And so, Game of Thrones gave itself an amazing opportunity to upend all storytelling and go bold with the most logical and satisfying ending possible: the death of nearly all humanity in Westeros.  They had the chance for the bummer of all bummer endings and they blew it.  But it wouldn’t have been a bummer ending just for the sake of a bummer ending, it would have been a bummer ending because it would have fit the narrative that had been laid out for seven years. 

Look, I knew it wasn’t going to happen.  But I held out hope until about the last three minutes of this episode right before Arya flew out of the sky (seriously?) to kill the Night King and essentially end the threat that has been building and building for eight seasons.  In one fell swoop, the largest threat to humanity was killed.

Give me a break.  What was the point of all of this?  Why was the Night King so stupid to walk right into a trap?  Why did they leave Bran alone with Theon and about 10 other Ironborn to protect him (even though this stupidly worked out in the end)?  And why did Arya even have to jump in like she did anyway when she probably could have just shot the Night King with a dragonglass arrow from safety somewhere (or anyone could have done that for that matter).  I’m so bummed that the show let everyone off the hook with such ease.  I’m sure more characters will die and ‘bad’ things will happen before the ultimate conclusion but the greatest threat to humanity on Westeros is gone. 

So, here’s the ending I would have written before this bullshit and the one I would write now that the army of the dead has been so stupidly defeated.

My Ending:

The Battle of Winterfell happens.  Just about everyone dies, since they are essentially outnumbered 100:1 (or more, we were never really told).  A small handful of core characters escape the battle once it becomes clear there’s no chance of survival, for the sake of this let’s say Dany, John Snow, Tyrion, Sansa.  A few others can survive this too just for some added drama for the next series of events, let’s say Sandor Clegane, Jorah Mormont.  Everyone else dies.  All the Dothraki die. 

SIDE NOTE: All the Dothraki died in the battle but Jesus Christ, what a wasted opportunity in this last episode.  After they all went charging in (and uh, what were they supposed to accomplish here exactly?  What was this strategy?) and all their lights were extinguished, why didn’t the Night King raise them all?  What should have happened is they all should have charged BACK at Winterfell, but this time they’re all undead fighting for the Night King.  I don’t think we saw a single undead Dothraki Screamer in this episode, although we did get, I believe, a single Thenn – super.

Anyway, everyone dies.  All the Dothraki.  All the Unsullied (Grey Worm ESPECIALLY) die.  All the Wildlings die (Tormund Giantsbane ESPECIALLY).  Just about everyone in the crypt dies (VARAS ESPECIALLY).  All the Northmen and Knights of the Vale die (including Robert Arryn who should have found his way to the crypt as well).  The army of the dead destroy Winterfell. 

However, that small group escapes.  They flee to King’s Landing to warn Cercei.  Now they’re like, ‘okay, seriously, we need to work together or else everyone on this continent is dead, do you get it?’  Cercei agrees, now she needs the Golden Company and the few remaining fighters from the north to work together to save humanity.

But it’s too late and there simply aren’t enough fighters to hold off the Night King.  The army of the dead makes it to King’s Landing and kills everyone.  They kill Sandor Clegane, then he gets raised and Undead Sandor Clegane kills his brother, the Mountain.  The Mountain gets raised (again, of sorts) to also fight for the Night King.  Tyrion dies.  Brienne of Tarth dies, is raised, and kills Jaime Lannister.  John Snow dies as he’s ravaged by countless undead.  Sam Tarly is killed, gets raised, and kills Gilly and her baby.  The Golden Company is wiped out.  It’s a total bloodbath.  Almost nobody is spared. 

However, the three remaining female heads of their families escape (four, if you include Yara) on Yara’s ship.  The show ends with Cersei, Sansa, and Dany escaping, sailing east to Essos.  They leave together in stunned silence, trying to figure out where it all went wrong.  Even Cersei is like, “fuck, I should have listened.”  The final scene is the Night King, standing in a completely destroyed King’s Landing, watching them sail away.  He’s surrounded by all the dead.  He stares off to the sea, thinking about how he’s going to make it over to Essos to finish the job.  He raises his hands to lift the dead (mostly just the Golden Company at this point) and the show cuts to black, the end.

This is the ending I’ve been prepared for (even though I knew this would never happen).  George RR Martin created this amazing looming threat, and in the end they should win because nobody bothered to deal with them this whole time.  But no, they are stupid and walk into the worst trap ever (which happens to work) and they are exterminated.  Ugh. 

Okay, so now that that’s definitely not happening, here’s the only ending at this point I’m going to be satisfied with (also not going to happen):

I don’t care who wins, it really doesn’t matter at this point.  Based on the fact that Martin killed off the Night King as if he never mattered in the first place (and did he?  What was the point of all this?), I’m sure this is going to get the Wayne’s World “Super Happy Ending,” whatever that is.  Probably Dany and John Snow ruling together after eliminating Cersei and the Golden Company.  Hell, maybe even Brienne, Grey Worm and Gilly make it out alive at this rate.

Anyway, I don’t care who wins.  Let’s just say Dany and John because that seems most likely at this point.  Fine, great, whatever, they win.  In the last episode, John explains that the White Walkers were defeated thousands of years ago, they were just defeated again, and in turn, they might be coming back.  So, they have to build a new wall, the last one stood for thousands of years just fine until the undead found themselves with a dragon. 

The show ends similarly to how it began.  A new wall is being constructed.  A few rangers from the New Night’s Watch are out ranging when all of a sudden, it gets really cold, crows start flying overhead and a new White Walker emerges, and cuts their heads off.  The threat never really went away and never will.  The end.

It’s all I can hope for at this point.